Are refurbished phones worth it? $650 later, I have some advice

Andrew Hoyle/CNET

With the iPhone 11 Pro and Samsung Galaxy S20 Ultra coming in at over $1,00zero and even the “affordable” OnePlus 8 Pro costing $899, I needed to see what degree of phone I may get with out spending a fortune. So I went on a hunt with $650 of CNET’s cash (thanks, guys!) to see what high quality of handset you will get once you purchase used. 

I’m based mostly within the UK, so I principally used eBay and a service known as MusicMagpie that buys outdated, undesirable phones, refurbishes them and sells them on. There are related providers within the US comparable to Gazelle. It additionally signifies that the telephones had been paid for in kilos, however I’ve given forex conversions all through for reference.

Now enjoying:
Watch this:

What $650 value of used telephones appear to be


Without additional ado, this is what I received.


Andrew Hoyle/CNET

Amount paid: £120 ($150, AU$230)

Originally launched: April 2015

Bought from: eBay, from refurbishing firm

Advertised situation: Grade A, “excellent” 

Actual situation: Almost as new. No scratches on glass entrance or again, no notable scuffs to metallic edging, slight beauty put on to metallic edge round digicam unit. Screen and headphone jack in excellent order. MicroUSB energy socket could be free and generally requires cable to be jiggled earlier than it fees. 

Do I belief it?
Despite the slight difficulty with the charging cable, this phone performs nicely and every thing else is in excellent working order. I’ve had no sudden crashes or different glitches that will trace at defective {hardware}. I’d haven’t any drawback utilizing this as my most important phone.


Andrew Hoyle/CNET

Amount paid: £56 ($70, AU$110)

Originally launched: March 2014

Bought from: eBay, non-public vendor

Advertised situation: “Used”

Actual situation: Aside from a few small marks on the top-right and bottom-left corners, only a few noticeable indicators of wear and tear and tear on the phone casing. Display, charging port and headphone jack all in excellent working order.

Do I belief it?
Absolutely. I’ve had no crashes, no restarts and the phone appears simply as easy to make use of as I bear in mind it being after I reviewed one other mannequin again in 2014. 


Andrew Hoyle/CNET

Amount paid: £50 ($60, AU$95)

Originally launched: September 2015

Bought from: eBay, non-public vendor

Advertised situation: “Used — condition is excellent”

Actual situation: Minor put on to the rubber backing materials of the phone however in any other case no main marks to talk of. Screen is scratch-free and works nicely. 

The battery, nonetheless, appears to have severe points. Multiple occasions the phone has shut down with out warning, regardless of the battery degree being over 50%. The phone would then flash up a battery empty image and never activate till plugged into an influence supply. At which level it might show the identical battery degree (over 50%) and would let me restart the phone. On different events, it might energy on solely to right away shut down once more.

Do I belief it?  
No. It’s tough to pinpoint whether or not the problems I’ve seen up to now are to do with an growing old battery (which might be anticipated to an extent in a six-year-old phone) or one other difficulty fully. Regardless, having the phone shut down like it is a main drawback, and I would not be snug utilizing it, not realizing if it’ll give up with out warning.

It’s a disgrace because the Moto X‘s “Pure Edition” Android — a pared-back model of the working system — operates extraordinarily easily for such an outdated gadget, with no noticeable lag as you swipe round. This phone doesn’t qualify as “excellent” situation and I’ll be trying to ship it again for a refund — watch this area.


Andrew Hoyle/CNET

Amount paid: £75 ($95, AU$145)

Originally launched: September 2014

Bought from: eBay, refurbishing firm

Advertised situation: “Grade B: good condition — The housing may have slight scratches and scuffs; There may be signs of scratches on the screen which may have been picked up from day-to-day usage.”

Actual situation: Almost no noticeable indicators of wear and tear and tear on the physique or show of the phone. Came with a display protector preapplied. The battery has aged, nonetheless. The phone shut down with out warning and on restart displayed the message: 

“This iPhone has skilled an sudden shutdown as a result of the battery was unable to ship the mandatory peak energy. Performance administration has been utilized to assist forestall this from taking place once more.” 

Do I belief it? 
Not actually. The warning message is an indication of an aged battery, and the result’s that efficiency will likely be throttled on the phone to cease additional crashes. Or, within the settings, I may decide to place up with extra crashes, with out the efficiency being throttled. Neither is a perfect possibility.

The “battery health” part within the phone’s settings says the batter has a most capability of 91% in comparison with when it was new, which does not appear too dangerous. However, the “unexpected shutdown” message is repeated in the identical settings menu. 

My choices could be to simply put up with the difficulty and proceed with a throttled phone, or attempt to have the battery changed by Apple or a third-party firm. Apple quotes a value of £49 ($49, AU$79) for battery alternative which is rather a lot to spend, provided that the phone was solely £75 to start with. 


Andrew Hoyle/CNET

Amount paid: £215 ($270, AU$415)

Originally launched: April 2017

Bought from: MusicMagpie

Advertised situation: “Good — This product has signs of wear and tear but has been fully tested and is in great working order.”

Actual situation: Very minor scratches to the show and a few small chips to the corners of the metallic edging. Display itself is in full working order, as is the digicam, the USB-C charging port and the headphone jack. 

Do I belief it? 
In my first few hours with the phone I’ve discovered zero points with the handset. I’d be completely snug utilizing this as my most important handset. 

What have I realized?

As with something, you get what you pay for. The Galaxy S8 works extraordinarily nicely and comes with the peace of thoughts of a 12-month guarantee from MusicMagpie. But at £215 ($270), it was the most costly of the bunch by far.

The Moto X was a giant disappointment, regardless of its low £50 value. It’s not in working order and I’d not be capable to use this phone as my most important gadget. The iPhone’s battery difficulty is according to what’s anticipated of an older battery and the phone will at the least be completely usable, albeit with throttled efficiency, for a while. Not too dangerous for £75.

Both the HTC One M8 and Galaxy S6 have up to now proven zero points and I’m trying ahead to placing them via additional assessments to see simply what you will get out of used telephones at these costs. 

If you are shopping for used telephones your self, it is value remembering that there are execs and cons nonetheless a lot you spend. An older phone will value you much less, however aged batteries and different potential {hardware} faults could imply you are probably not getting the discount you hoped for. 

It’s additionally necessary to keep in mind that these older telephones will not have latest variations of Android on board. That not solely signifies that some new apps will not be appropriate along with your phone, however the telephones could not have necessary safety updates that might go away you susceptible. 

Source link

Tarun Banerjee

Professional Web Designer & Developer,Expert in SEO & Digital Market, Founder of Tech Hunt.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.